Harun Farocki: The Real, Constructed, and Predicted Wind
How digital images shift us from representation toward simulation—and reshape visual literacy.
Show notes
Show transcript
00:00:04: Welcome to Art Unquoted, I'm Charlotte Desaga
00:00:07: and I am Esenija Bannan.
00:00:09: Where two billion based art professionals who think that in a world of noise revealing things can sometimes be found in few words
00:00:19: In each episode we take single quote & see where it leads us This is Spark&Friction
00:00:33: Today.
00:00:34: were diving into your quote from the late Harun Faroqi A German filmmaker an artist who spent his career dissecting the politics of images.
00:00:44: The quote is from his final work, Parallel One Till Four a four-part series about the evolution of computer generated images.
00:00:53: he said
00:01:05: it's a deceptively simple statement isn't?
00:01:09: I
00:01:09: mean, on the surface it sounds almost trivial.
00:01:12: But one of those observations is that once you hear it... ...you can't unhear anymore!
00:01:19: It completely changes how you look at digital images.
00:01:23: Just recently we both saw Harun Farouk's show and major final work Parallel One to Four at his gallery representation in Berlin.
00:01:36: It's an impressive four-part video essay that functions as an archaeology of the digital image.
00:01:43: And in it, Faroukhi meticulously traces the evolution of computer graphics over thirty years by focusing on how video games have attempted to represent the real world and I think we were both quite impressed with this.
00:01:58: Oh absolutely!
00:02:04: In really what makes digital images fundamentally different from film, whether it is analog or digital photography.
00:02:12: I see in films you have this connection to the real world even if using a wind machine and still creating something physical that's captured fully on camera.
00:02:25: there are distinctions between whats real with feeling what's constructed.
00:02:32: Yeah, but in computer images that distinction is gone.
00:02:36: all wind is equally artificial equally constructed by code and there is no real wind to capture.
00:02:44: it's all just simulation.
00:02:46: And that's Faroukis point isn't?
00:02:48: That computer images don't represent reality.
00:02:51: they constructed from the ground up and he as he says a new kind of constructivism.
00:03:00: That's what I find the most fascinating in Farouk's work.
00:03:04: He is arguing that computer graphics, even as they become more and more photorealistic They are moving further away from the logic of photography And In a way closer to the logic Of painting.
00:03:18: just as photography freed painting From the obligation to represent reality?
00:03:29: from the same obligation, don't you think?
00:03:32: I see the parallel he's drawing but i'm not sure entirely if i entirely agree.
00:03:38: Photography was a radical break because it had an indexical relationship to reality.
00:03:44: The light that bounced off of the object Was this same light that hit the film and It was a direct trace.
00:03:51: Digital images have no such connection.
00:03:54: they are pure information so To say there.
00:03:57: freeing photography feels a bit outside generous.
00:04:03: It's more like they're replacing it with something else entirely.
00:04:09: Yeah, and I guess that's exactly the crazy part.
00:04:12: if something so unique... And how does even all evolve?
00:04:17: How is he not just about replacing it but opening up new possibilities for what an image Can be, and I'm curious to see if an image no longer has to be a representation of something that exists in the world.
00:04:31: Maybe it can be a proposition... ...a model?
00:04:35: A world itself its own thing!
00:04:38: Let's think about how artists are using CGI and three-D modeling today.
00:04:43: Do they really just create realistic simulations?
00:04:47: They're building entirely new visual languages But
00:04:51: are they...?
00:04:54: Or are they just getting better at mimicking the visual language of cinema?
00:04:58: Farouk himself was very critical about how computer games for all that technical sophistication still rely on conventions or film.
00:05:08: The first person shooter perspective, cinematic cutscenes and narrative structures.
00:05:16: He even expressed dismay that montage the collision of images to create meaning was being replaced by this seamless and endlessly flowing moments of game worlds.
00:05:28: Yeah, That's a fair critique but it does point out true what makes digital image so powerful.
00:05:35: they created immersive continuous world In habit, we can step into and become part of it.
00:05:43: That's a different kind experience totally from the critical distance that Montage creates.
00:05:49: It is almost like more about presence The physical presence And the embodiment.
00:05:55: Artists are exploring that too.
00:05:57: Think of virtual reality works by artists such as John Raffman Or the immersive installations of Hito Steyer.
00:06:05: But this is where I get skeptical.
00:06:06: Is that immersion always good thing?
00:06:09: Or does it just make us more susceptible to the seductive power of simulation?
00:06:14: If there's no distinction between real and constructed, how do we maintain a critical perspective.
00:06:25: And what does inhabit mean in the context of virtual world?
00:06:28: I doubt that i can actually fry an egg with zeroes at once when hungry
00:06:36: Simultaneously, I think that's exactly the question Farouk is asking us to consider.
00:06:42: He isn't saying digital images are good or bad either-or he just says they're different and we need a new way of looking at them –a new kind visual literacy.
00:06:56: I understand that even we see a tree, it doesn't smell in the video game and its okay.
00:07:04: It's not representation of A tree but constructed object with its own internal logic.
00:07:11: And maybe if you perceive like this If take lightly then changes everything.
00:07:17: So for your two wins are metaphor to different ways understanding world One based on representation one based simulation
00:07:27: Absolutely.
00:07:29: And maybe that's Farouk is telling us, Maybe he wants to hear and know.
00:07:36: we're moving from one to the other.
00:07:40: That may be.
00:07:41: digital imagery always existed.
00:07:43: We just now learned how to access it.
00:07:46: How do you use?
00:07:47: And what does this mean?
00:07:50: Whether for art or politics For understanding reality itself?
00:07:57: Now we have like a volume of AI generated images, which takes Farouk's point even further.
00:08:04: There is no camera No wind machines nor physical process at all.
00:08:08: just algorithms predicting pixels.
00:08:11: Yeah exactly and that's where it gets unsettling.
00:08:15: with the video game At least there's the programmer making Intentional choices, but with generative AI we don't even know what logic is creating the image.
00:08:26: It's a black box!
00:08:27: So Faroukis' distinction between two kinds of wind becomes three – The Real Wind, The Constructed Wind and now the Predicted Wind.
00:08:37: I like the predicted wind.
00:08:39: it's nice way of describing its not trying to simulate reality anymore.
00:08:47: One can say extrapolating from patterns and data?
00:08:53: Yeah, which means we've even furthered any connection to the real world.
00:08:57: We have no framework yet for understanding what that means!
00:09:05: I don't know.
00:09:12: It's just a statistical noise and without meaning, without intention we're left with nothing but hallucinations pretending to be an image.
00:09:23: Yeah... We are witnessing something unusual like the emergence of new kind of creativity?
00:09:32: That is beautiful idea!
00:09:33: But it looks already now that we have handed tools for reality making by simulating creativity to corporations and governments.
00:09:44: It seems like we always live in a world of competing narratives, searching for something new to chase then looking at it complaining about.
00:09:54: the difference now is that AI makes construction visible?
00:09:59: It shows us meaning was made yet not found could also be an opportunity create new meanings maybe even new ways of seeing and then with this, new possibilities.
00:10:12: New meanings?
00:10:14: I just... or the flattening in all meaning into a kind visual consensus doesn't create the strange or difficult.
00:10:25: it averages them out.
00:10:27: It's a triumphs of mediocre in super fancy dress.
00:10:30: i would say
00:10:32: Super fancy dress!
00:10:33: I like that.
00:10:35: let us see You know, let's say maybe.
00:10:38: But artists will use it to subvert that and they'll push it break it interrogate It which I always like.
00:10:46: when artist do That.
00:10:47: And thats what Artists Do with every tool They have in their hands In that creative process... ...they Will discover things we can't yet imagine Maybe even themselves cannot Imagine or expect to imagine Not despite the technology but because of it.
00:11:04: Yeah, let's see.
00:11:05: I mean...I'm curious to inspect these discoveries once they come along and i hope that will bring along good quotes
00:11:13: for us.
00:11:15: You never know artificial intelligence!
00:11:17: That is a big exploration and lot you think about.
00:11:21: but join next time on Art Unquoted And thats all the time we have today.
00:11:31: If you enjoyed this episode please subscribe to artunquoted wherever u listen.
00:11:36: It helps other listeners find
00:11:38: us.
00:11:39: We'll be back soon with more ideas to unpack!
00:11:42: Thank you for listening.
New comment